Questions and answers - page 4 | Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani

Sunday January 17, 2021 AD Jumada al-thani 3, 1442 AH

(69) Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani rejects imitation from scholars with the reason that it is just useful for conjecture and conjecture does not have authority in Islam and he knows it one of the causes for divisions of Muslims since long time ago to this day. Yet further he does not even consider Ijtihad to its commonplace meaning which is interpreting laws from conjectural reasoning, correct with regards to invalidity of conjectural reasoning in Islam and he knows it necessary to figure out another solution to achieve certainty. (Article 1)

Questions and answers

First/Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next/Last

Q&A about

Code

Number

Code

Subject & content

Author

Date

Appendix

48	48	Introductions; Knowledge; Necessity of and how to gaining knowledge (Ijtihad) What is his opinion about other rational sciences (other than philosophy)? Like the science of logic and the science of Kalam[1] etc.? Because he has pointed out that he is not interested in the science of philosophy; because he considers it very abstract and inapplicable. Does he have the same opinion about the science of Kalam and the science of logic and other rational sciences taught at seminaries and universities?	Ali Razi	01/11/2015
47	47	Morals; Moral vices; Arrogance What is the law for kissing the hands of rulers or scholars or parents? What is the law for kissing the hands of the Messenger of God (peace be upon him and his household) and the Imams of Ahl al-Bayt (peace be upon them), especially his Excellency Mahdi (peace be upon him)?	Ali Razi	01/11/2015
46	46	Morals; Moral honors; Dhikr (remembrance), Dua (praying), Tawakkul (trust in God) and Tawassul (seeking help) What is his honor’s opinion about the prayers (Dua) that the Shiites read for his Excellency Mahdi peace be upon him? Such as Faraj prayer, Nudba prayer, Iftitah prayer etc.	Ali Razi	01/11/2015
45	45	Laws; Prayer (Salah); The daily necessary prayers The Shia use a Mohr[1] for prayer. What is his opinion? Is Sajdah i.e. prostration on the soil of Imam Hussein’s peace be upon him tomb and the soil of Karbala recommended?	Ali Razi	01/11/2015
44	44	Laws; Principles and rules of Fiqh What is the opinion of Allamah Khorasani about Comparison? Furthermore, what is his opinion about Istihsan[1]?	Ali Razi	01/11/2015
43	43	Introductions; Knowledge; Impediments to gaining knowledge; Imitation With greetings and respect to his most honorable Allamah Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani may God protect him, please explain if it is permissible to imitate scholars in case of knowing their reasons?	Hamed Moqaddam	26/10/2015
42	42	Laws; Marriage, Hijab and sexual relations What is the law of chairwomanship and management of women? Should we refrain from obeying a chairwoman or manageress? Is it okay to shake hands with female colleagues in accordance with customary and social rules and regulations and not out of pleasure?	Ali Razi	21/10/2015
41	41	Laws; Prayer (Salah); Adhan and Iqamah Does saying the phrase «أشهد أنّ علیّاً ولیّ الله» in the Azan abrogates it? Shi’a scholars do not consider it as a part of Azan, but do not forbid saying it either (by reasoning based on verse 55 of Surah Al-Ma’eidah). Is Mr. Khorasani’s opinion the same?	Ali Razi	21/10/2015
40	40	Beliefs; Cognition about the Hereafter; Raj’ah (return to the world), Holul (incarnation) and reincarnation The Shi’a believe in the Raj’at of some God’s friends and truthful and martyrs after the advent of His Excellency Mahdi peace be upon him. What is his honor’s opinion about this?	Ali Razi	21/10/2015
39	39	Beliefs; Cognition about faith and disbelief (Kufr); Faith and its grades The Shi’a Muslims believe that Justice and Leadership are the principles of religion in addition to Monotheism, Prophethood, and Resurrection. What is his opinion in this regard?	Ali Razi	21/10/2015
38	38	Laws; Forbidden businesses and occupations What is the law of drawing and installing the picture of the Messenger of God peace be upon him and his household and the Imams of Ahl al-Bayt?	Ali Razi	21/10/2015
37	37	Laws; Forbidden businesses and occupations What is his honor’s opinion about the religious law of chess game?	Ali Razi	21/10/2015
36	36	Introductions; Proof; The book of God; Authority, miracle and dignity of Quran Is numeric miracle of Quran true? Some scholars confirm it by referring to the last verse of Al-Jinn Surah and 59th verse of Al-An’am Surah and other verses and narrations. For example, some of the Shiite, provide some examples from the Quran for this reason to prove the principles of belief, such as the fact that the number of verses in which the words Imam or A’emmeh are presented are 12, which is equal to the number of Imams and the Prophet’s caliphs, and this is a miracle of Quran and also other examples.	Ali Razi	21/10/2015
35	35	Laws; Vow, covenant and oath What is the law of vowing to give Nazr[1] for Imam Hussain peace be upon him and the rest of Ahl al-Bayt peace be upon them in Muharram and Safar days and other days of the year?	Ali Razi	18/10/2015
34	34	Morals; Moral vices; Insulting and unjust cursing If damning the murderers and enemies of Ahl al-Bayt peace be upon him causes incidence of disagreement with Sunni brothers, then what is the Islamic law in this regard? In Ziyara Ashura[1] some of them are explicitly named. Many of Sunnis respect Yazid[2] as a caliph! Some Sunni scholars like Imam Muhammad Ghazali even believe that damning Yazid and his army is wrong and believe that God might forgive them!!!	Ali Razi	18/10/2015

First/Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next/Last

Download collection of questions and answers

Questions; Return to Islam; Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani

Any usage and utilization from the content of this website provided that proper citation is made, is allowed.