Critiques and responses - page 2 | Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani

Writing a critique

* Please click here to write your critique, but it is better to read the related critiques and responses before doing so. For this purpose, you can look at the list of subjects, or use the search feature.

Dear user! You can write your scholarly critique about the works and thoughts of Allamah Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani in the form below and send them to us to be scholarly responded in this section.

Attention: Your name may be shown as the author of this critique in the website.

Note: Since our response goes to your email address and is not posted in the website necessarily, it is important that you put your email address correctly.

Please note the following:
1. Your critique may have been responded on the website. Therefore, it is better to review the related critiques or use the search feature on the website before writing your critique.
2. It is better to avoid writing multiple and unrelated critiques at a time; because such critiques are being responded on the website separately and possibly for a period longer than usual.

* Please enter the letters and numbers written in the image.

Subject of the critiques

Introductions

The intellect

Knowledge

The necessity and method of gaining knowledge (ijtihad)

Impediments to gaining knowledge

Imitation

Superstitions and other impediments

Attributes and duties of scholars

Proof

The Book of God

Authority and attributes of the Quran

Guidance on some verses of the Quran

The Caliph of God

The necessity and attributes of the Caliph of God

The method to know the Caliph of God (the miracle and the text)

Narrations from the Caliphs of God (ahad and mutawatir)

Rulings

The principles and guidelines

The ancillaries

Critiques and Responses

<</<1 2 >/>>

Critiques & responses about

Code

Number

Code

Subject & content

Author

Date

Appendix

13	13	Beliefs; Cognition of the Caliphs of God; Mahdi; Mansoor and his movement to prepare the ground for the advent of Mahdi; The identity and attributes Why does his honor call himself Khorasani? Email his reasons! From false claimants researcher!	Ali Asghar	2015-02-09
12	12	Introductions; Knowledge; Attributes and duties of scholars On your website, you have mentioned the infidel West, the such and such America and the true Islam several times. These statements are well-known in Iran, and have been heard from religious people for decades but have not had as good an effect as wheat seeds. The biggest mistake in the current world is handing over the government of countries to religious people, which has unambiguously left its undesirable effects on the political, economic, military and social administration of countries; as you can see that the people in Iran are stuck in a quagmire under the rule of a religious government. In the age of space and the Internet, religious people and their entourage will never be able to lead a nation to comprehensive development. We have heard from the past «شرف المکان بالمکین», which means the honor of any place depends on the person who sits in that place. The religion in a position of lies, discrimination, monopoly and hundreds of other defects cannot lead mankind to honesty and righteousness. Human history has not shown such a thing so far.	Mahmud Farzin	2015-02-05
11	11	Introductions; Proof; The Book of God; Guidance on some verses of the Quran I read the book Return to Islam. In fact, it was more correct and closer to the truth compared to the Shia thought, but Khorasani, like all Shias, is considered a polytheist and disbeliever as well; because he has interpreted the verses of the Quran according to his opinions; because if you read what comes before and after of the verses which he has brought as reasons for his opinions, you will realize that they have nothing to do with the context of the discussion; of course, most of the verses, not all of them. As for example, in the verse of purification, God Almighty addresses all the wives of the Prophet, whereas Mansoor proves the guardianship of the Ahl al-Bayt by it, and considers it exclusive to Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Husain, peace be upon them. Although there is no doubt about their purity and righteousness. I recommend that this author carries out some research first to find out whom he worships; because what you and the Shias say really surprises God!	Ahmad	2015-01-30
10	10	Beliefs; Cognition of the Caliphs of God; Mahdi; Mansoor and his movement to prepare the ground for the advent of Mahdi; The identity and attributes I read his book. Of course I read some parts a few times and I read some parts faster. To be fair, as much as I have knowledge of the religious sciences, I did not see any flaw in this book and almost all of it are truths that have been reminded. But the fundamental question is how can I make sure that he himself follows these truths practically and with certainty? (For example, whether he is not like me, the humble servant who may be a sinner and my faith may be incomplete). Considering that we still have not seen his performance with our own eyes and clear evidence. Of course, according to Holy Quran, we cannot deny everything that we have not seen, and believing in the unseen is one of the signs of faith (the first verses of blessed Surah Al-Baqarah). Perhaps one of our reasons is that he is the promised Khorasani and, according to the authoritative and Mutawatir statement of Imams of guidance, he, in addition to telling the truth, indeed follows it practically as well.	Ali Zaeim Zadeh	2015-01-24
9	9	Beliefs; Cognition of the Caliphs of God; Mahdi; Mansoor and his movement to prepare the ground for the advent of Mahdi; Actions and goals Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani, in his book, has not deprived any group, faction, sect and country of his criticisms, and has attacked them all from one side! Neither the Shiite, nor the Sunnite, nor the Salafi, nor the Sufi, nor the Ahl al-Hadith, nor the philosophers, nor the poets, nor the scholars, nor the guardianship of jurisprudent, nor democracy, nor the West, nor the ISIS, none of them is confirmed by him and none of them are considered in accordance with his so-called pure and complete Islam! Therefore, he has not left anyone for himself, and has displeased everyone! It is obvious that the Muslims of the world are either on that side or on this side and he has reacted against both sides! Therefore, there is no one left to support him! Everyone has become his enemy! Had he had a little politics, at least at the beginning of his movement, he would have kept at least one person for himself and would have not driven everyone away from himself! Anyway, now nobody considers him as a friend and everyone has taken a stand against him, and from Iran to Saudi Arabia and from ISIS to America, all are on one side and he is on another side! Therefore, it is clear that his work will not come to a conclusion and his failure is certain! He has no politics in my opinion.	Kianoush Qasempour	2015-01-24
8	8	Rulings; The ancillaries I read the book “Return to Islam” twice carefully. I did not understand it very well the first time, but I got it the second time. To be fair, it is a well-written and different book and I learnt a lot from it, especially from the parts it has explained cognition and its impediments, and the parts about the impediments to return to Islam, also my field of study is theology of religions and mysticism. In my opinion, these words they say that this book is deceptive and does not have reasoning and such, are absurd, because they themselves cannot write a book at this level, and if this book is deceptive, their books are blasphemies!! However, to be honest, I did not understand one part of the book and I have a problem and I think there is a contradiction. In one part, in the subject of “Performing some parts of Islam is contingent on performing the entire of it”, the author has said: “performing the Islamic Hadds[1] by those who do not know the entire laws of Islam and are not capable of administering all of them, is not permissible, without the legitimacy for non-performing the Islamic Hadds by them be permissible”! How is it possible that performing Islamic Hadds by them is not permissible and is also obligatory at the same time?!! This is contradiction and impossible! Of course, maybe I am wrong. Please guide me.	Mojtaba Salehi	2015-01-22
7	7	Beliefs; Cognition of faith and disbelief; Religions, madhhabs and sects I have a question to ask his honor. The Prophet peace be upon him and his family said: “My ummah will divide into 73 sects, all of them will be in the Fire except for one”. So, how does his honor claim all of them are not right except for one and that is the one he has brought now and has named it Hanif Islam?	Murteza Savaari	2015-01-21
6	6	Introductions; Proof; The Book of God; Guidance on some verses of the Quran I have a few questions from his honor: First, if the religion of Islam which currently exists, is not the very Islam at the time of the Prophet, then why does God say in Quran: «إِنَّا نَحْنُ نَزَّلْنَا الذِّكْرَ وَإِنَّا لَهُ لَحَافِظُونَ»[1]? Has God not been able to preserve His religion from distortion during 1400 years?? Second, if the religion of Islam which currently exists, is not the very Islam at the time of the Prophet, then what will happen to those many Allamah and great people whom even his honor [Allamah Khorasani] learned under their teachings?? Does it mean all of them have died on false religion? Even his honor’s [Allamah Khorasani’s] masters??	Morteza Savari	2015-01-21
5	5	Introductions; Proof; The Book of God; Authority and attributes of the Quran Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani does not consider conjecture as proof and believes only certainty is proof on one hand, and he considers the Book of God from the sources of Islam on the other hand, while according to the consensus, the book of God is conjectural and is not definite, and only the Sunnah[1] is definite. Therefore, if he believes that conjecture is not proof, then it is also not permissible to hold on to the book of God!	Abdullah Dastjerdi	2015-01-19
4	4	Beliefs; Cognition of the Caliphs of God; Mahdi; Mansoor and his movement to prepare the ground for the advent of Mahdi; The identity and attributes According to our researches, “Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani” is a nickname!	Unknown	2015-01-17
3	3	Beliefs; Cognition of the Caliphs of God; Mahdi; Mansoor and his movement to prepare the ground for the advent of Mahdi; The identity and attributes I did not know his honor before and even did not hear his name! I did not see any biography nor a picture of him on the internet too! It is not known at all if such a person exists! Assuming that he exists, it also is not known if he is Shia or Sunni! What kind of pure and complete Islam is this to which he invites and in which has disproved “absolute guardianship of Faqih” and has mentioned the names of Ahl al-Bayt without “peace be upon him”?! If he is Shia, he should have mentioned the names of Ahl al-Bayt with “peace be upon him” and if he is Sunni, at least should have mentioned their names with “Allah is pleased with him”!	Javad Qasemzadeh	2015-01-15
2	2	Introductions; Knowledge; Attributes and duties of scholars How on earth is it possible that all these scholars and jurisprudents and mujtahids throughout centuries and ages have not realized all these aspects about Islamic beliefs and laws and now at this time, Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani has realized them all?	Mohammad Sadiqian	2015-01-03
1	1	Introductions; Knowledge; Impediments to gaining knowledge; Imitation If in the opinion of Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani, Hadiths (with the exception of a few of them) are conjectural, then where can I find religious laws other than the treatises of the eminent maraji’ al-taqlid (muftis)? Considering that he does not approve of ijtihad either! Where do I take the laws of the prayer that the Quran has said about: «إِنَّ الصَّلَاةَ كَانَتْ عَلَى الْمُؤْمِنِينَ كِتَابًا مَوْقُوتًا» (An-Nisa/ 103) which means, “Undoubtedly the prayer is obligatory for believers at specific times”? Where do I take the laws of fasting that the Quran has said about: «يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا كُتِبَ عَلَيْكُمُ الصِّيَامُ» (Al-Baqarah/ 183) which means, “O you who believed, Fasting has been made obligatory upon you”? And many other laws for actions that have been made obligatory in the Quran. Should I leave them for now and start training myself and many other people so that the Caliph of God on the earth may appear, and then perform the prayer and fasting and so on?! That does not make sense at all!	Morteza	2015-01-02

<</<1 2 >/>>

Download collection of critiques and responses

Critiques; Return to Islam; Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani

Login

Login

Subscription to the newsletter