Criticisms & investigations
Generals; The content of the book
The book “Return to Islam” is full of claims and empty from reasons! I have never read a book that is to such an extent full of claims and empty from reasons!
|Answer to criticism:||1||Date:||06/01/2015|
In the book “Return to Islam”, there are several reasons from the book of God and Mutawatir Sunnah of the Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi wa 'Alihi wa Sallam and wisdom requirements for every non-trivial and uncertain claim and this is totally clear and obvious for anyone who looks at it; even for some of these claims, the reasoning have been exaggerated and has surpassed the limit of sufficiency; to such an extent that, in many pages of this book, there is a verse of Quran or a ruling from wisdom in every line and this is totally clear and obvious for anyone who looks at it. By this description, one of the following results would be concluded from your word that says this book is empty from reasons:
1 . You do not consider the book of God and His Prophet’s Mutawatir Sunnah as reason.
2 . You are among the deniers of authority of the intellect;
3 . You have vision problems.
Also, when you say you have never read a book which is full of claims and empty from reasons to this extent, then there would be no conclusion other than you have never read a book so far.
May God grant all Muslims succeeding in honesty, fairness and leaving arrogance.
Mansoor Hashemi Khorasani
The section for investigating criticisms